Almost Famous (2001) – Commentary

>> Back to gallery


I am probably not alone in having Almost Famous to thank for my at least once a week Tiny Dancer habit. Cameron Crowe likes to have a sing-a-long-a-scene in his films and in this particular production it is that bit on the bus where the band and their ‘aids’ sing an a capella rendition of Elton John and Bernie Taupin’s paene to California’s bounty of beautiful women.

Whilst a splendid scene it also serves as a good illustration of a lasting effect of films like this, an effect that I would describe as ‘misplaced nostalgia’. To elucidate,what I mean is the infection by a slightly melancholic yearning for a time that you have no physical experience of living, other than the fictional memories which we mentally construct after viewing period films amplified by our personal enthusiasms for both the important and the ephemera emanated by a given historical period.

A serious case of nostalgia is symptomised by a heavily idealised view of the past, indeed, much like Almost Famous itself. It boasts a great script and some excellent performances (Philip Seymour Hoffman as Lester Bangs soliloquising on the meaning of a vocation as a writer comes to mind) but more standout were the graphic elements of the production design. As a retrospective recreation of something that was once a reality the collateral on show was of utmost importance. It was therefore very necessary that the Stillwater logo looked like it could have been drawn by the same person that did the one for Crosby, Stills & Nash, ditto any featuring album sleeve, poster, ticket stub, t-shirt, venue marquee etc etc.

The point that I am striving for is that nostalgia very often has a negative connotation, particularly when talking about graphic design and popular music. I would go so far as to say that when we say graphic design in this context what is brought to mind are the products stocked by Portobello Road giftshops rather than serious artistry. But the reality is that period recreation is a privileged process wherein the makers are able to have an overview of the collective archive of everything that is surviving and then can cherry pick the most relevant for their purposes.

The outcome, particularly when fictional and not a representation of actual existing material, needs to work hard in order to avoid any parody and pastiche that may let the script and the actors’ performances down. For a sense of nostalgia to be established the realism has to be complete. In those terms the products of nostalgia, far from being cheap imitation, should be viewed as being more authentic in graphical function than the real thing. After all, would an unconvincing recreation make us wish we were on a Greyhound bus group-singing  AOR?

– –

n.b. “Every great work of art has two faces, one toward its own time and one toward the future, toward eternity” – Lester Bangs